Guest Article

From a Father’s Debt to a Shariah-Based Settlement: A Story of Patience and Sacrifice Among His Children

From a Father’s Debt to a Shariah-Based Settlement: A Story of Patience and Sacrifice Among His Children
  • Published OnNovember 18, 2026
Mufti Ashfaq Kazi
When the issue of inheritance comes down to dividing land, houses, shops, flats, or money lying in a bank account, it often happens that brothers become distant from one another, sisters begin to feel like strangers in their own family, and relationships that a father nurtured with love throughout his life begin to weaken before the value of a few properties.
However, when the command of Allah is given priority in matters of inheritance, when one remains conscious not only of one’s own rights but also of the rights of others, and when the sanctity of family relationships remains alive in the heart, the very inheritance that could have divided a family can instead become a means of bringing it together again.
The reality is that inheritance is a system ordained by Allah Almighty. While explaining the shares of children, the Qur’an clearly states:
“Allah instructs you concerning your children: for the male, a share equal to that of two females.”
(Qur’an 4:11)
In many worldly matters, people are given room for consultation and mutual agreement. However, the basic shares of inheritance have been determined by Allah Himself.
Unfortunately, while we are often extremely careful about Salah, fasting, Hajj, and Zakat, when the time comes to distribute inheritance, sometimes love of wealth, family considerations, or long-established customs begin to prevail over the clear commands of Shariah.
In some families, a daughter is told, “You were given dowry at the time of your marriage, so you no longer have any share in the inheritance.” Elsewhere, a sister feels embarrassed even to ask for her rightful share in the property left by her own father. In some cases, even the mother’s rightful share is overlooked.
It was against this background that, on Thursday, 14 October 2021, after Zuhr Salah, a meeting was held at Darul Ifta wal Irshad, Juma Masjid of Bombay. This was not merely a meeting for the distribution of inheritance; rather, it was an effort to bring together the hearts of a family that had been facing a complicated inheritance matter for nearly six years.
A well-known personality from Bombay had passed away approximately five or six years earlier. The deceased had two wives: six children from the first wife and four from the second, making a total of ten children. The daughters were all married and attended the meeting accompanied by their husbands as mahrams.
The estate of the deceased included residential property, land, four or five flats, approximately three offices used by the companies, other properties, and two companies. Despite the considerable assets and business interests involved, no formal settlement of the inheritance had been reached for nearly six years.
The difficulty was not merely about determining who should receive what. The major issue was that the deceased also had outstanding debts amounting to approximately ₹4.5 to ₹5 crore.
The eldest son clearly presented the details of these liabilities before all the brothers and sisters. They included funds belonging to certain individuals connected with company affairs, investments received on account, government tax liabilities, company deposits, and other financial obligations.
Thus, on one side stood the estate, and on the other stood debts amounting to crores of rupees. The sisters had their Shariah-prescribed rights, while the brothers faced the responsibility of settling their father’s debts. At the same time, there was a business established by their father through years of hard work—a business upon which the livelihoods of several people depended.
To bring the matter from the realm of emotion to the ground of reality, every property was discussed in detail. Approximately nine major assets were reviewed, including the two companies and their associated premises, lands, the ancestral residence, four or five flats, and approximately three offices being used by the companies.
The value of each property was determined through mutual discussion and consensus. In some cases, different valuations were suggested. One person would propose one figure, another would suggest a different figure, and eventually a value would be agreed upon by everyone.
In terms of residence, the children of the two wives were living in or using different properties. The married sisters, however, had practically received nothing from their father’s estate until then.
During the discussion, one of the brothers produced a document prepared by the deceased father. Initially, it was thought to be a will or a will deed. Upon closer examination, however, it became clear that it was actually an incomplete document relating to a partnership. It had neither been registered nor did it contain the necessary details and signatures of witnesses.
In that document, the deceased had named different sons as partners in different companies. However, merely writing someone’s name on a document does not complete a valid Shariah gift (hibah). Since the required conditions for the actual transfer of ownership had not been fulfilled, this document could not be treated as the basis for the Shariah distribution of the estate.
The eldest son also presented details of expenses and related financial matters. It was made clear during the meeting that the settlement should neither cause injustice to anyone nor be imposed through coercion. Rather, everyone’s rights had to be determined according to Shariah principles, justice, and mutual consent.
With this objective, four possible arrangements were considered.
The first option was to determine the present market value of the company, deduct its outstanding debts and financial liabilities, and then distribute the remaining net value among the heirs according to their Shariah shares. The future profits and losses of the company would then remain the responsibility of those who continued to operate it.
The second option was to allow the brothers to retain and operate the company while agreeing upon a fixed settlement amount for the sisters in consideration of their respective shares—for example, ₹50 lakh for each sister—with a period of two or three years allowed for payment.
The third option was to value all the properties and distribute them according to the prescribed Shariah proportions. With both widows surviving, their combined share was one-eighth (12.5%), to be divided equally between them. The remaining 87.5% would then be distributed among the children according to the Qur’anic principle:
“For the male, a share equal to that of two females.”
In other words, each son would receive twice the share of each daughter.
The fourth option considered was to allow the brothers managing the company to continue operating it on the basis of a Mudarabah arrangement. They would receive an agreed share in consideration of their work, while the remaining brothers and sisters would continue to participate according to their respective shares.
Such a decision could not be made within a few minutes.
Nearly four to five hours were spent in careful discussion and deliberation. At times, everyone discussed the matter together. At other times, individual sisters were called separately along with their husbands so that their personal views could be heard freely. Each sister was given an opportunity to express what was truly in her heart.
This was not simply an exercise in putting prices on properties. Behind every valuation stood a relationship. Behind every decision stood the memory of a father. And attached to every Shariah share was the future of an entire family.
Then came the moment that changed the direction of the entire matter.
It should be noted that this was a religiously conscious family, and three concerns existed simultaneously in everyone’s heart.
First, no heir’s rightful share of inheritance should be lost.
Second, the deceased father’s debts, amounting to crores of rupees, had to be paid.
Third, the company that the deceased had established through a lifetime of effort—a business whose licences and commercial standing would not be easy to recreate, and upon which several families depended for their livelihood—should not be destroyed because of an inheritance dispute.
These three concerns made this meeting different from an ordinary inheritance conflict.
If the sisters had looked only at their own rights, their demand would have been entirely legitimate. If the brothers had focused only on the burden of debt, their difficulty was also genuine. And if everyone had thought only about saving the company, there was a danger that someone else’s rights might be overlooked.
The effort, therefore, was to find a just solution in which no one’s rights were violated, the father’s debts could be paid, the business could continue, and the sisters could receive their rightful settlement.
Finally, after several hours of discussion, mutual consultation, and separately hearing the views of the sisters, a beautiful moment arrived.
All the heirs mutually agreed upon a settlement amount. It would not be appropriate to disclose the exact figure, as it was a private matter entrusted to those involved. What deserves to be remembered, however, was the remarkable attitude of the sisters.
They told their brothers, in effect:
“Continue running the company, pay our father’s debts, and pay us the amount agreed upon for our shares gradually over the next two or three years.”
This was more than an agreement over money.
It was an expression of trust in their brothers, loyalty to the memory of their father, and a quiet but extraordinary decision to protect their family from breaking apart.
These sisters had practically received nothing from their father’s inheritance for six years. They could have insisted upon the immediate fulfilment of their Shariah rights. Instead, through mutual consent, they chose a path of patience, accommodation, and sacrifice.
For the brothers too, the situation was far from easy. Their father’s debts, the responsibility of the company, and the rights of their sisters all stood before them at the same time. But when the sisters showed generosity of heart, the burden on the brothers’ shoulders became lighter—and eyes filled with tears.
By the grace and mercy of Allah, a matter that had remained unresolved for nearly six years was settled peacefully in that very meeting.
There was no need to knock on the doors of the courts. There were no rounds of police stations or legal offices. Family relationships were not destroyed, nor did brothers and sisters become estranged from one another.
The sisters left not merely with a financial settlement, but also with the heartfelt prayers of their brothers. The brothers left not merely with an agreement, but carrying a lifelong debt of gratitude for their sisters’ sacrifice. And both mothers were granted peace of heart.
When inheritance is distributed with the command of Allah before us, with respect for the rights of others alongside our own, with the fear of Allah in our hearts, and with love for family relationships, then inheritance itself can become a means of keeping a family united.
Wealth eventually leaves our hands. Properties remain behind. Businesses change with time. But a sister opening her heart for her brother, a brother acknowledging the rightful share of his sister, and a family finding a path of justice before reaching the steps of a courtroom—these are treasures upon which no monetary value can be placed.
May Allah Almighty preserve the love, trust, and spirit of sacrifice within this family. May He forgive the deceased, create ease and means for the repayment of his debts, and grant all the heirs the ability to fulfil their respective Shariah obligations and respect the rights of one another.
Ameen.
The short URL of the present article is: https://english.fikrokhabar.com/hubg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *